Transferring a Foreign Pension (QROPS and Similar): U.S. Tax
Reviewed by the Fairlight Accounting cross-border tax team — U.S. & Canadian Tax Desks
A foreign pension transfer moves retirement savings from one plan to another — most commonly a U.K. pension into a "qualifying recognised overseas pension scheme" (QROPS) in Malta or Gibraltar, or a move between employer plans across a border. The transferring country usually allows it tax-free. The United States has no tax-free rollover between foreign plans, so for a U.S. person the transfer may be a taxable distribution.
On this page
Why can a tax-free transfer abroad be taxable in the U.S.?
Because U.S. rollover rules apply only to U.S. plans. A transfer out of a foreign pension is, by default, a distribution to you followed by a contribution to a new plan — and a distribution from a foreign pension is taxable to the extent it exceeds your basis, unless a treaty article preserves deferral. If the originating plan was treaty-protected (a U.K. employer pension under the U.S.–U.K. treaty, for example) and the destination plan is in a country with no such protection (Malta's treaty is narrower; Gibraltar has no U.S. treaty), the transfer can end the protection and trigger U.S. tax on the full value in one year.
How does the destination plan's status matter?
Three questions decide it:
- Is the destination plan a "pension" under a U.S. treaty? The U.S.–U.K. treaty protects qualifying U.K. plans. The U.S.–Malta treaty's pension provisions were tightened after schemes marketed to Americans claimed they allowed tax-free withdrawals; the IRS has publicly rejected those positions. Gibraltar, the Isle of Man, and most other QROPS jurisdictions have no U.S. treaty at all.
- Is it a trust for U.S. purposes? Many QROPS are trusts, bringing Form 3520 and 3520-A annual reporting with penalties measured as a percentage of the assets.
- What does it invest in? Transferred funds usually land in a portfolio of non-U.S. funds — passive foreign investment companies — each with Form 8621 reporting unless the plan is protected.
A transfer that was tax-efficient for a U.K. resident can be the single most expensive tax event in an American's life.
What about transfers between employer plans when moving countries?
Moving from a German employer plan to a Canadian one, or consolidating plans after a career across borders, raises the same questions: a deemed distribution for U.S. purposes unless both plans are protected and the treaties permit it. Transfers into a U.S. plan from a foreign plan are generally not permitted as rollovers either; the foreign plan's distribution is taxable and the U.S. contribution is subject to normal limits.
What has to be reported?
The distribution (if taxable) on Form 1040; the destination plan on the FBAR and Form 8938; Form 3520 and 3520-A if the plan is a trust; Form 8621 for funds held inside an unprotected plan; and Form 8833 if a treaty position is being claimed on the transfer or the plan's treatment.
Is there a way to transfer without U.S. tax?
Sometimes, when both plans are treaty-protected and the treaty articles cover the transfer, or when the amount above basis is small. More often the honest answer is that the transfer should either not be made or should be modeled as a taxable event with the U.S. tax built into the decision. Promoters' assurances that a scheme is "recognized" refer to the transferring country's rules, not U.S. tax.
Frequently asked questions
My adviser says the QROPS is tax-free for Americans. Is that right?
The IRS has specifically challenged this for Malta schemes, and a 2021 competent authority arrangement under the treaty closed it. Treat such assurances with caution and get an independent U.S. analysis.
I transferred years ago and never reported it. What now?
The transfer year may have had a taxable distribution, and the plan may need Form 3520, FBAR, and Form 8621 for every year since. The Streamlined procedures cover this pattern if it wasn't willful.
Would leaving the pension where it was have been better?
Often yes, for a U.S. person — a treaty-protected plan in its home country usually keeps deferral; moving it rarely improves the U.S. position.
Does this apply to transferring a Canadian plan?
Transfers between Canadian registered plans are generally respected under the U.S.–Canada treaty; transfers out of Canada to another country are a different analysis.
Next step
Fairlight Accounting handles U.S. domestic, cross-border (U.S.–Canada), and international tax returns, plus bookkeeping, payroll, and CFO advisory. If you're considering a pension transfer — or made one and are unsure what it meant for your U.S. return — our team can analyze both plans and the treaty before anything else moves. See pricing or book a free fit call.
Cross-border taxes, handled in one place
U.S. and Canadian filings prepared together by our U.S. and Canadian Tax Desks.
Book a free fit call